| Platinum | Pepe's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Pepes Trattoria |
| Silver | Pepe's Pizza |
| Bronze | Calabria Ristorante |
| Top Pick | 2 Chefs Italian Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Bertucci's |
| Top Pick | Dino's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mare E Monti |
| Top Pick | Oxfords Casual Dining |
| Top Pick | Rosalina's Kitchen |
| Dell'Ovo's Kitchen |