| Platinum | George's Coney Island |
| Gold | Boulevard Diner |
| Silver | Oxfords Casual Dining |
| Silver | The Coop |
| Bronze | Brickstone Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Brick and Stone |
| Top Pick | J. Anthony's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Ms. Worcester |
| Top Pick | Regatta Deli |
| Top Pick | The Other Place Pub |