| Platinum | I Love Frankie's, Worcester's Best Pizza |
| Gold | Volturno Pizza |
| Silver | Amici Trattoria |
| Bronze | Pizza Chef |
| Top Pick | Central Pizza |
| Top Pick | Go Grande |
| Top Pick | Kelley Square Pizza |
| Top Pick | Papa George |
| Top Pick | Reunion Tap & Table |
| Top Pick | Tony's Pizza |
| 2 Chefs Italian Restaurant & Bar |